Monthly Archives: March 2011

An Argument for 7 Speed

It has been quite the while since last post. School has been busy, so I offer no apologies. What I do offer is my take on the now “outdated” 7-speed drivetrain. That is, 7 in the rear, as I am an avid lover of double/ triple (especially triple!) cranksets for any mult-purpose machine – they help a lot for loads and/or hills.

What with 8, 9 and 10 speeds all commonly available from Campy, SRAM and amongst the ubiquitous Shimano offerings, I hear many call 7 speed dead. I say, far from it! Its still here, baby, as strong as ever! Actually, probably even more so, although in low-level groupsets available like Tourney. Why do I like this drivetrain so much? Not all for the performance, for sure, or I’d be rocking a 10 speed Dura-Ace’d bike, but rather I feel that 7 speed has a good balance of availability, low pricepoint, durability, and yes, performance in there too:

Advantages I see:

-7 speed freewheels can be retro-fitted to an ol’ ten speed (provided a washer is added if the spacing is 120mm, or it just comes down to a simple replace if you have 6 speed/ 126mm spacing in the rear)
– Cheap, cheap cheap! These freewheels and (still available) freehubs for 7 speed are cheap, as are the casettes and chains to go with ’em. Don’t expect to shovel out much more than $7-8 for a mid-level chain, $15 for a quality freewheel, or $20 for a decent Shimano/SRAM casette cluster.
-The availability! The price has come down for 7 speed due to Shimano’s technology trickle-down, so these are found from forms mid-high through entry-level (and still rather usable) drivetrain grouppos on all sorts of bike stor or dept. store bikes. So, there’s not worrying about spares on the road, and they’ll still be here for a while. Cheap shifters are a bonus here, as budget-conscious thumbies/grips/trigger shifters can be a blessing for a cheap hybrid/commuter set-up. Oh, and they still work with 8-speed STI brifters or bar-ends.
-For durability, 7 speed is pretty darned good. They use the same chains as 8 speed, so 8/7 shouldn’t make any difference there at all in turns of chain/cog life. However, when comparing 9/10 speed systems, 7/8  lasts much longer; the wider and hence more robust chain/ cog tooth profiles mean longer component life, and hence, cheapness can go to a whole new level, not to mention….
-…. ease of use! With more speeds, one has to know their bicycle well enough to keep their derailleurs, shifters and chain in working order. This especially applies to index shifting in the rear. 7 speed requires more precision that 5 or 6 speed,  a little be less than 8, but noticeably so for 9 or 10.
– There may be a small difference going from 7 to 8, or 8 speed to 9, but a change from 5-7 speed, or even 6-7 makes quite a bit larger difference. Here’s why; fractionally, the increase from 7-8 or 8-9 is only 1/8 and 1/9 closer cog range, respectively. With five speed, it goes to 2/7 closer cog range (my math may be wrong here, but the idea behind it checks out!). The fractions don’t lie. That much. Also, 7 speed, as opposed to 5/6 speed systems, supports the “hyperglide” style gear profile, which improve shifting *a ton*. A metric tonne.

– Racing/ Ergo shifters are hard to come by in 7 speed, although 8 speed shifters seem to work quite well, if you don’t mind having a ‘ghost’ position left over. The same goes for bar end shifters.
– The % change between cogs can be quite noticible, when compared w/ 9 or ten speed systems. I find that I cannot quite hit my ideal cadence many times, which can be a bummer when riding for high efficiency/ speed.
– You don’t have the elite status of havign 30+ speed on your machine. Now no one wants to be your friend.

Other that these quips, I believe that the 7 speed drivetrain still deserves additional time to be considered relevant and functional ina time when more = better. But, I’ll allow you to disagree with me.